"A first-rate prose stylist, [Holmes] was perhaps the most quotable of all judges, as this ably edited volume shows."-Washington Post Book World
"Brilliantly edited, lucidly organized, and equipped with a compelling introduction by Judge Posner, [this book] is one of the finest single-volume samplers of any author's work I have seen. . . . Posner has fully captured the acrid tang of him in this masterly anthology."-Terry Teachout, National Review
"Excellent. . . . A worthwhile contribution to current American political/legal discussions."-Library Journal
"The best source for the reader who wants a first serious acquaintance with Holmes."-Thomas C. Grey, New York Review of Books