Since his college days Todd has been haunted by the image of one of his fraternity brothers falling to his death. Not certain whether he witnessed an accident or a murder, Todd has remained silent all these years to protect a host of secrets including his own. Now, twenty years later, the past boils into the present when a young man appears and a baby girl vanishes. Todd's former college girlfriend Janice Gray, who is now openly gay, confesses to having secretly given birth and given away a child.
Who fathered the child, Todd or perhaps another young college man, a guy with whom Todd was also intimate? Understanding this mystery, however, not only forces to light the truths of Todd's and Janice's pasts, but also places them in grave danger. Certain members of a strict religious group, it seems, prefer that their sexual secrets remain hidden in their pasts in strong part to prevent the truth of the fraternity death from surfacing in the present.